AAP Says Circumcision is Safer Option

The American Academy of Pediatrics' new policy says circumcision should be covered by insurance, and that the health benefits far outweigh any risk.


To circumcise or not to circumcise — that has been the controversial question posed to every parent of a newborn boy for decades in the United States.

Circumcision rates peaked at over 90 percent in 1964, according to Circumstitions.com. Since then the practice has declined in regularity to nationwide estimates that range from 33 percent (MGMBill.org) to 55 percent (CBS News).

“Over the last five, almost six years, between 2007 and 2012, there has been a slight decline in circumcision procedures, from 58 percent to 55 percent,” says Good Samaritan Hospital Spokeswoman Leslie Kelsay. “We don’t know if a 3 percent change is statistically significant." 

Good Samaritan Hospital services residents down the Highway 87 corridor to Highway 101 in the cities of Campbell, Monte Sereno, Los Gatos, Saratoga, West and Central San Jose and Cambrian.

Despite circumcision's steep drop in popularity, the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) changed its official stance on the procedure on Monday. According to Parenting.com, the AAP is now saying that "the preventative health benefits of infant circumcision clearly outweigh the risks."

In both 1999 and 2005, the AAP remained staunch that circumcision was "not essential to the child's current well-being."

After several years of study, Michael Brady, M.D., chairman of the department of pediatrics at Nationwide Children’s Hospital in Columbus, OH, said "it’s now obvious there’s a preventative effect" associated with circumcision. 

Namely, circumcision has been shown to be positively correlated with lower HIV rates in heterosexual males in Africa, low HPV rates and smaller risk of contracting syphilis and genital herpes. In addition, studies have shown that circumcised babies are less prone to urinary tract infections, and that the procedure can reduce the risk of penile and prostate cancer later in life. 

Some opponents of circumcision cite decreased sexual pleasure, but according to Parenting.com, "study participants in Africa who had been circumcised as adults reported either no effect or increased pleasure." Other opponents claim the operation is barbaric and unfair to the infant, who has no ability to choose.

Dr. Brady, who serves on the AAP Task Force, suggested that circumcision be included in Medicaid coverage. A study at John's Hopkins found that opting not to circumcise could cost $313 in related health care expenses to a person over a lifetime. The projected health benefits of circumcision are used to justify the AAP's recommendation for universal coverage for the procedure. 

According to MGMBill.org, just 22 percent of baby boys in California were circumcised in 2010. West Virginia lead the country with a circumcision rate of 86 percent that same year. See MGMBill.org's graphic of circumcision rates by state in the photos above.

-Mayra Flores De Marcotte contributed to this article

What do you think of the AAP's revised stance on circumcision? Do you agree? Disagree? Do you think the reported health benefits are enough? Share your thoughts in the comments area below!

Ellen Simon Pifer August 29, 2012 at 05:54 PM
Choosing to circumcise your son is a personal choice. That said, if you do choose to circumcise, for your kid's sake use a mohel. Having a doctor do the procedure is like going to a doctor instead of a jeweler to get your ears pierced. We have the region's most experienced mohel living here in Los Gatos --Rabbi Moshe Trager. He's done more than 4000 procedures. It's all he does. In addition to the benefits outlined in the AAP statement, a mohel does the procedure in a matter of seconds vs. several minutes with a doctor. The baby isn't tied down when you use a mohel, nor is he shot up with needles, which cause more pain than the whole procedure. Studies have shown the best pain control is sucking sugary water -Rabbi Trager uses grape juice or wine and speed. A urologist told me to use Rabbi Trager and the experience was night and day compared to the experience we had using a doctor.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »