patching...
Update: A solar eclipse begins at about 5:15p today, Sunday, May 20; click here to learn how to make a pinhole projector & view safely. »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Moms Talk Q&A

How Have You Educated Your Children About 9/11?

Schools lack curriculum, so it's sometimes up to parents alone to figure out how to raise awareness about the effects of the Sept. 11 terror attacks.

 

Although my children were born into a world touched by the devastation and terror of 9/11, they have been untouched by hatred or violence of any kind.

So as we approached the 10th anniversary of the worst terror atttack in the history of the country, I was torn. I felt the weight of the anniversary and wanted to do something to recognize the importance of what happened.

What to do? Protect their innocence or open their eyes?

I decided to talk to them about it. So on 9/11, I asked them what they had heard about the deadly attacks a decade ago. I shared with them what I had learned about the hijacking of the planes and the destruction they caused in New York City, the Pentagon and in Shanksville. My youngest child asked me why, and I could not answer her. We kept the conversation short.

That night when I went to bed, I formulated a plan for the next day. I wanted it to be a Zen day. A day of peace and love. A day to enjoy nature, art and music.

Instead, it was a frustrating day of bickering and petty annoyances. I had a headache for most of the day and was so tired I took a nap in the afternoon.

That night, I told my girls that I wanted us to do something after they brushed their teeth. My older daughter asked, “what?” I told her I wanted to talk about something, and she rolled her eyes.

After we were ready for bed, I lit some candles and turned off the lights. I told them I wanted us to each think about one thing we could do to share love and peace in the world. We stretched our bodies and thought, and then each of us shared our idea and lit a candle.

We lit candles for kindness, patience, and helping people; then we continued to talk. We had more ideas about how to spread peace and love.

After that, my older daughter suggested we each name a fear and blow out a candle to blow away that fear. So we blew away meanness, misunderstanding and violence. Then together we picked war and having enemies, and we blew those away, too.

We left three candles glowing as we climbed into bed for story time.

How have you educated your children about 9/11?

Thanks to Kim Ratcliff for last week’s Moms Talk question: Do you think parenting has reached a state of paranoia? Should we watch over our children Big Brother-style?

Here’s what some readers had to say:

Kristina Strand

8:46am on Wednesday, September 7, 2011

I have three sons, all of whom look very much alike, but who might as well be from three different planets. I do not think on-size-fits-all. My response to each of them when I hear: "that's not fair, you didn't make so-and-so do that!", is "you are different people and we parent each of you as best we can". That being said, thus far trust has worked out pretty well for us, so long as it is not violated. We provide clear boundaries, which widen as each of our sons develop (this is not always at the same chronological speed). Our boys know we care, that we are watching, and that when there is a consequence (whether natural or imposed by us) it is almost certainly because they have overstepped a boundary which was clear to them, and which they chose to overstep. For us, parenting is neither policing nor is it closing our eyes. For us it is an every-changing job which requires communication, love, trust and vigilance.

LG2010

9:16am on Wednesday, September 7, 2011

Obviously your child is young and you can joke about it. But just wait until he is in high school - things will change. Kids are much smarter and more resourceful today. There is an abundance of drugs at Los Gatos High School, and anyone who disagrees is in denial. They say they are going to a friend's house, then end up at a party. I've even heard of parents who allow their kids to drink at home "because at least they are safe here."
Yes, you have to aware of your kids’ moods and activities. Verify and confirm everything. You may think that your kid is a "good kid" but even the good kids are doing stupid things!

Mary Smith

1:07pm on Wednesday, September 7, 2011

When my daughter was in high school, she had a friend who stole from me. I will call this friend Kathy. She was 15 at the time.

What Kathy stole was not valuable - only a blush compact from my medicine cabinet. But it was brand new, and its disappearance was hugely obvious - especially since I went into the bathroom and noticed it was gone immediately after Kathy came out of the bathroom!

I confronted her right on the spot. She was embarrassed, started crying, but was actually relieved and grateful!

Kathy's mother had let her do whatever she pleased. Kathy had no boundaries or curfews. And you know what? Kathy HATED it! She had all this freedom, which kids THINK they want. But she didn't have the maturity to manage her life. She WANTED the structure and she said so! She truly wished her mother "would care enough to say no once in a while".

Kids not only NEED boundaries - they WANT them. They just don't always know it!

Maaliea Wilbur

9:49pm on Wednesday, September 7, 2011

What a great conversation you started Kim! I think monitoring children and teens in today's society is a must! Working as a teen therapist in LG, it has become clear that teens crave boundaries and structure in all areas of their lives. Unfortunately, due to the high demands of modern day parents, teens aren't getting what they need and are having to learn the hard way...eventually making their way into my office and onto my couch. I agree that as a community, it is time to not only recognize the drug and alcohol problem amongst our teens but to do something about it. Due to my passion for this concern, I recently launched an intensive therapeutic substance abuse program for teens and their families.

To learn more go to www.therapyworksoflosgatos.com

About this column: Each week in Moms Talk, our Moms Council of experts, headed by moms Dyan Chan, Maaliea Wilbur, Jennifer Croll and mom's coach Carrie Vawter-Yousfi take your questions, give advice and share solutions. Related Topics: 9/11, Dyan Chan, Love, Maaliea Wilbur, New York City, Sept. 11, kim ratcliff, moms council, moms talk, and peace
Have a question you'd like the Los Gatos Patch Moms Council to help you answer? Tell us in the comments.

AR

9:53 am on Wednesday, September 14, 2011

want to educate children about 9/11? take them on a field trip to a gas station.

Reply
Comment_arrow

AR

10:46 am on Wednesday, September 14, 2011

the author responded "i don't know" when one of her children asked why the 9/11 attacks took place. its been ten years, we need to move past the glib self-induced myth that dark-skinned muslims just woke up one day and decided they couldn't stand the fact that we can vote and wear revealing clothes.

everywhere around the world, children receive stark and brutal lessons in geopolitics. its time our kids stopped being an exception to this. if we want to stop repeating painful errors, we need to start evaluating our world factually. don't people ever wonder why the US is even hip-deep in the mideast? OIL. we love paying less for gas than anyone else in the industrialized world, so we might as well come to grip with the implications.

since ww2, all the industrialized nations understood cheap oil would be the key to economic growth. in 1953 the US went on the offensive and orchestrated the coup of the *elected* leader of iran, who had the temerity to want to distribute oil profits among his citizens. its been downhill ever since, and we've bankrolled and supported anyone who will keep the oil flowing, regardless of how despotic or dictatorial. its been back and forth ever since.

indeed, osama bin laden published a document explaining exactly why he attacked us on 9/11: our support of repressive arab regimes, our soldiers in saudi arabia, and our support of israel.

Dyan Chan

8:39 am on Thursday, September 15, 2011

Hi AR,
Thank you for your comment. I agree that we need to work to understand ourselves and each other, and speak out or up for what we believe in, starting in our own families and neighborhoods, and extending to our policy makers and national and international communities. I do also hope to teach my children that violence is not the inevitable answer to differences.

Reply

Chigiy Binell

11:58 pm on Thursday, September 15, 2011

Hey Dyan,
I think the time you spent with your kids the night of 9/11 was beautiful. I love the part about blowing away the fear. Your kids are still too young to understand all the ins and outs of 9/11 of course. I agree with some of what AR is saying. It is good to teach the older kids what led up to 9/11. Understanding the whole story can perhaps prevent such a horrific event from happening in the future. I watched the film shot by the two French brothers about the new NY firefighter on 9/11 with my kids. I had seen the film before and I thought it was important for my boys to watch.

Reply
Patch_comments_icon

Sheila Sanchez

3:56 pm on Monday, September 19, 2011

Hi Dyan, thank you for this very important question. Even though the anniversary of 9/11 has passed, we should be talking about how the CDE still lacks formal curriculum on this. It's such a shame because without it being discussed in the classroom, children are left with wrong information about the attacks. I fear this is reason No. 1 why there are so many stereotypes against Muslims. It's time the CDE take action on this. Thanks again for contributing to our Moms Council and helping bring up a topic that not only parents, but teachers are concerned about.

Reply

Leave a comment